Supreme Court blocks controversial Texas social media law


The Supreme Court voted 5-4 to block Texas’ social media censorship law, a major boon for tech companies that fought against content moderation laws that would fundamentally change the way they do business.

Why is it important: Conservative states have launched a legal war against social media companies in a bid to stem what they see as a wave of censorship, but this decision, like other recent rulings, suggests they face a rise to prominence in the courts.

What is happening: The Supreme Court’s decision means Texas cannot enforce a new law that would allow Texans and the state’s attorney general to sue tech giants like Meta and YouTube over their content moderation policies.

  • The court order is not a final decision on the merits of Texas law, but when the courts freeze a particular law or policy, it is often a sign that the measure faces a difficult road on the bottom.
  • This comes just days after a federal appeals court ruled against a similar law in Florida.
See also  Germans worry about war and inflation | TAUT | 02.06.2022

Catch up fast: Texas passed its law last September and opponents immediately challenged it in federal court, winning an injunction suspending it from taking effect.

  • But earlier this month, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the law could go into effect immediately.
  • Opponents appealed this decision to the Supreme Court and won.

Details: Justices Amy Coney Barrett, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor, Brett Kavanaugh and Chief Justice John Roberts voted to restore the lower court injunction and block the law from taking effect.

  • Judges Neil Gorsuch, Elena Kagan, Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas voted against.
  • Alito wrote a dissent, saying, “It’s not at all clear how our existing precedents, which predate the internet age, should apply to large social media companies.”
See also  How Macron's failures created an ungovernable France

And after: The case returns to the District Court, where arguments from both sides will be presented on the merits.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here